Share
Stick Electrode Arc Deflection: Electrode Problem or Magnetic Arc Blow?
When a stick-welding arc will not stay where it is directed, inspect the electrode and the welding setup before choosing a remedy. This guide separates consumable checks from magnetic arc-blow investigation and explains what a useful comparison can establish.
01Describe the arc before blaming the electrode
A stick-welding arc that repeatedly pulls away from the intended location needs investigation. Record whether it bends forward, backward, or sideways; whether it occurs at the root, an end, or a corner; and whether the behavior recurs at the same joint location with different electrodes. Increased spatter or an uneven bead alone does not identify the cause.
Magnetic arc blow is deflection caused by an unbalanced magnetic field. Current flow through the work and residual magnetism can contribute. TWI describes the effect in DC welding and warns that uncontrolled deflection can lead to lack of fusion. This is a reason to investigate affected welds, rather than judge the problem only by surface appearance. [1]
02Check the supplied electrode and its condition
Start with the consumable actually issued: trade designation, classification, diameter, lot identification where available, and the applicable welding procedure specification (WPS). Confirm the manufacturer's permitted current type, polarity, position, and operating range. A familiar classification does not authorize a different setup.
Inspect unused electrodes for coating damage and preserve suspect samples with their packaging. ESAB's consumables handbook states that mechanically damaged electrodes with missing coating should be scrapped. This supports rejecting damaged rods; it does not prove that every deflected arc comes from coating damage. Follow current instructions for the particular product when reviewing storage or re-drying. [2]
The Askaynak Inverter 205-SUPER troubleshooting table separately lists an electrode eccentricity problem and a magnetic-field effect among possible causes of the symptom it calls arc blow. These are distinct investigation paths. A visual check can identify obvious damage, but an acceptable-looking rod is not a measurement of coating concentricity. Retain samples for the supplier's examination if that question remains. [3]
03Use a comparison that can answer a specific question
The following comparison plan is an editorial troubleshooting framework, not a reported Bridge Brand experiment. Carry it out on authorized trial work with the required protection and inspection.
- Keep the electrode designation and diameter, joint detail, polarity, settings, and technique consistent as far as practical. Record any unavoidable difference.
- Compare suspect stock with traceable, correctly handled stock of the same product and diameter. Preserve the identity of each sample.
- Record where the deflection starts and whether it follows particular rods or remains tied to the same part of the joint.
- Then investigate the return arrangement separately, recording the original and revised connection positions.
An improvement after replacement supports further investigation of the original stock, but does not by itself establish a manufacturing defect. A change of brand, classification, diameter, polarity, and current together makes the result difficult to interpret. If the original condition cannot be reproduced, record that limitation.
04Investigate location-dependent behavior
If the behavior remains at a joint end or root despite changing to suitable replacement rods, examine the magnetic explanation rather than repeatedly substituting consumables. Lincoln Electric explains that joint boundaries and the return-current path interact; relocating the return can help or worsen the combined effect. There is no single clamp position that fixes every joint. [4]
A published investigation by Watanabe and colleagues measured magnetic flux density using a simulated model for high-current MIG inside-seam welding of UOE pipe. It associated asymmetric fields with the return current and welding current through the inserted boom. That specific study supports checking the current path; its geometry and process are not a stick-welding parameter recipe. [5]
Where residual magnetism is suspected, TWI describes measuring in the assembled weld gap with a thin Hall probe and scanning around a pipe joint to locate the maximum. A reading taken elsewhere on the component may miss the relevant gap condition. Record the position and measurement setup. Do not turn a published rule of thumb into a universal acceptance limit. [6]
05Choose a correction within the approved procedure
| Finding | Supported next action | Boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Missing coating or damaged rods | Remove damaged electrodes from use; preserve identification and samples. | Re-drying does not repair missing coating. |
| Behavior changes with return position | Evaluate a documented return arrangement on representative trial work. | Keep a secure, appropriately rated connection; assess the whole joint. |
| Persistent magnetic deflection | Review arc length, current, and permitted current type with welding supervision. | Maintain fusion and all WPS requirements. |
| Significant residual field at the gap | Seek a controlled demagnetization or compensation plan. | Specialist setup and verification are needed. |
TWI lists a shorter arc, the lowest practical current for the joint, and AC where appropriate among mitigation measures. Changing to AC requires a compatible electrode and power source; TWI also notes that procedure requalification may be required. A smaller diameter or lower current is not acceptable if it prevents the required fusion. [6]
06Verify the weld and close the consumable investigation
Record the electrode identity, observed behavior, supported cause, correction, trial conditions, and examination results. Improvement in arc direction is a process observation, not proof of internal weld soundness. Assess affected production welds and repairs against the specified acceptance criteria before release.
If a consumable concern remains, provide the supplier with traceable samples, packaging information, operating conditions, and reproducible observations. That evidence is more useful than a bead photograph alone. Where both stock condition and magnetic effects remain plausible, keep both open until the evidence separates them.
Make a Consumable Complaint Traceable
Keep the supplied electrode, its handling history, and the actual joint conditions connected. A clear investigation protects weld quality and gives both the workshop and the supplier evidence they can act on.
Related BBKP Resources
Technical References
- [1] TWI — What Is Magnetic Arc Blow?
- [2] ESAB — Welding Consumables Handbook, eighth edition (2005), damaged coating guidance
- [3] Askaynak — Inverter 205-SUPER User Manual, Maintenance and Troubleshooting–4, printed page 49
- [4] Lincoln Electric — Prevent Arc Blow
- [5] Watanabe et al. — Prevention Against the Magnetic Arc Blow in DC Arc Welding of Pipes (1983), 52(2), 185–192; DOI: 10.2207/qjjws1943.52.185
- [6] TWI — How Do You Prevent Arc Blow?
This article combines published technical guidance with an editorial investigation plan. It reports no Bridge Brand experiment, product comparison result, or universal operating limit. The cited pipe study concerns its specified MIG configuration; current product instructions, project requirements, and the approved WPS govern production use.